NY-NJ border at the Hudson River. 5 miles from NYC!
http://wcbstv.com/local/big.black.cats.2.973931.html
http://wcbstv.com/local/big.black.cats.2.973931.html
more New England mountain lion rumors
- Thread starter funkyfreddy
- Start date
Help Support vftt.org:
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
DougPaul
Well-known member
Interesting, but it does not address the question that I consider most important if I encountered a mountain lion: "How do I minimize the probability of death (or serious injury)?".
(Notation: p(x|y) means the probability of event x given that y has happened.)
It examines p(death|activity, attack) as a function of activity while I want to choose the activity that minimizes p(death|sighting, activity).
p(death|sighting,activity)=p(death|activity,attack) * p(attack|sighting,activity)
The study, by the author's own admission, does not examine what to do to minimize the chance of an attack (p(attack|sighting, activity) in the first place and thus cannot answer my question. So it is possible that the traditional advice of make yourself "big" and face down the lion before the possible attack is still the best advice to minimize ones chance of death or serious injury.
Doug
sardog1
New member
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2003
- Messages
- 2,579
- Reaction score
- 231
I'd also like to see evidence that the size, age, and gender of the human victims was controlled for in the study. My initial response is that smaller, younger, and female victims were more likely to be targeted in the first place and more likely to freeze in a way that invited attack. No, I don't have any data to support this line of reasoning, just a hunch that bears investigation IMO.
DougPaul
Well-known member
It would be nice to see a real study...
Unfortunately the data would be hard to obtain. Anything based upon recorded reports would be biased toward incidents which resulted in serious injury or death. To get unbiased data, one would probably have to set up at a number of trailheads and get all returning hikers (including those killed by mountain lions
) to fill out a questionnaire.Doug
Chip
Well-known member
To get unbiased data, one would probably have to set up at a number of trailheads and get all returning hikers (including those killed by mountain lions
Doug
Right. including those who had no idea they were being stalked and consequently calmly continued walking or jogging through the area and away from the cat.
Those Rockland County black cats referenced above by rup are getting a lot of air time down here. Getting to be Big Foot status, though: If there are so many sightings (including a cat on a downed deer at a golf course) why has no one gotten a picture or collected any evidence ?
Last edited:
DougPaul
Well-known member
Simple: just get the cats to fill out questionnaires, too...
Actually, it shouldn't matter to the hiker as long he is unaware of the cat's presence and there is no attack. (And, of course, an attack will trigger awareness.) Presumably the hiker will not alter his behavior if he is unaware of the cat.
A questionnaire filled out by all hikers will implicitly cover this situation in the no sighting and no incident category.
Doug
Last edited:
Chip
Well-known member
Right. But if you're trying to determine the best way to avoid being attacked, the "unawares" calm continuance would add evidence to that "response", no ?
DougPaul
Well-known member
Perhaps, but until we can get the cats to fill out questionnaires, that evidence will be unobtainable.
FWIW, I'm sure that I (and many if not most of us) have been watched by animals that would cause us to alter our behavior (or at least mood) if we knew they were watching us.
Doug
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
sardog1
New member
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2003
- Messages
- 2,579
- Reaction score
- 231
"'We did not hear any snaps of twigs, no crunches of leaves; it was like it was a ghost,' Stout said. 'My son said it's a ghost cat.'"
Ayuh: Puma concolor:The Latin name for the cat of many names
Cougar. Catamount. Painter. Panther. Ghost cat. Puma. Shadow Cat. Mountain lion.
This one in Winslow, ME, sounds like the real deal. And I damn sure wouldn't be sending the kids out with bells thinking that will keep them safe.
Ayuh: Puma concolor:The Latin name for the cat of many names
Cougar. Catamount. Painter. Panther. Ghost cat. Puma. Shadow Cat. Mountain lion.
This one in Winslow, ME, sounds like the real deal. And I damn sure wouldn't be sending the kids out with bells thinking that will keep them safe.
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
LOL. When my family lived in the country my mother would ring a big cowbell when it was time for dinner.
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
DrewKnight
Active member
OK, definitely not a New England mountain lion story, but yikes:
Three "killer" cougars killed near Canadian town
Three "killer" cougars killed near Canadian town
Little Rickie
New member
funkyfreddy
Well-known member
Similar threads
