2 thumbs up
I have had these boots for about 3 years and they work very well. I must say I am a trail runner convert so I will not rave about their comfort, but as far as boots are concerned they are very comfortable when broken in. On another note, I have never had wet feet with these boots. I find when I wear them hiking I tend to seek out mug and water to walk through.
As for winter use, if you are just planning on doing some day hiking or snowshoeing, they will be perfect. I just climbed Moosilauke with them a few weeks ago without a bother. If your adventures are going to get abit crazier, I would suggest either a mountaineering boot or a nice insulated winter boot. I saw a guy climbing up Lions Head with these last weekend which is well beyond the ability of these boots.