Meo and LauraM
I must disagree. The Eiger film from the Banff festival was very dissapointing. If you saw the footage of the film also shown at Banff by Charles Houston "Exploring the Heights" where they showed climbers in 1938 and 1953 in the Himalayas using the old gear and looking perfectly natural and at home, you would have realized what a poor job those German guys did on Eiger. The guys in the Swiss film looked like kludges in comparison to the real fottage in the Houston film. They clearly didn't get familiar with the gear and you could see it.
Secondly, the mixing of footage and equipment of the Eiger film crew, using modern protection, ropes, etc. was in my opinion very unprofessional looking. You had the guys in 1930s gear banging a piton into a crack where a piece of modern protection was visible right there. Duh!
The German climbers may have learned how hard it was to adapt to older equipment in a short time but they certainly didn't convey a sense of how it was done, and done well in the 30s. The other film showed that marvelously.
Sure the gear matters, but if you saw only the Eiger film you may have thought how tough it must have been. If you saw the Houston film you would have realized it's not the gear, it's the climbers that make the biggest difference.
Eiger North Face - 1/2 star
Exploring the Heights - 3 stars
Pb